EXPERT WITNESSES AS TEACHERS
Many expert witnesses have spent years in front of a classroom. Such individuals have likely taught advanced undergraduate seminars, delivered papers at conferences, or even supervised dissertations. It would be natural to assume that such experience would serve well on the witness stand when an expert witness must explain—or teach—complex material with both precision and nuance. Often, it does not. The habits that build respect in the university—precision and comprehensiveness—can leave jurors confused and potentially searching for some other basis on which to decide whom to believe in a “battle of the experts.” This article examines why that happens and proposes a framework that experts and trial counsel can use when preparing testimony: the expert should approach the witness stand less like a university lecturer and more like a skilled high school teacher.
In the graduate or undergraduate classroom, students have typically chosen the subject, and they arrive with the necessary prerequisites. They know they will be tested, and they’re motivated to study material that does not come easily. If they fail to follow the material, they bear the consequences. These assumptions don’t hold true in a courtroom. Jurors are summoned, and they may bring with them no shared background or baseline curiosity about your area of expertise. Their education, occupations, and comfort with technical material vary widely. An expert cannot ask whether jurors are following or understanding the testimony. Jurors cannot interrupt to ask what a term means—and where courts do permit written juror questions, those come only after the testimony and pass through the judge. Jurors will hear the expert’s testimony once, unless curious enough to request a transcript. The testimony may begin toward the end of a long day or after hours of other complex evidence. But if they fail to, the consequences fall on the party.
Except for the consequences, a high school teacher works under conditions much closer to these. Students are required to be present, and they arrive with uneven preparation and interest. An expert cannot assume that a concept explained just once has been understood—particularly when a full understanding of the expert’s ultimate opinion depends on an understanding of those underlying concepts being taught. Ultimately, the job of a testifying expert is not to display mastery, but to transfer understanding to a particular group of people and to recognize whether that transfer has taken place.
HOW JURORS DECIDE WHETHER TO BELIEVE AN EXPERT WITNESS
Sometimes an expert witness will be fortunate enough to encounter a highly educated and sophisticated juror who closely weighs the soundness of the methodology and strength of the underlying data. The consequence of a mismatch between expert communication and juror understanding is that when jurors cannot readily assess the merits of an opinion, they must find other ways to determine which expert is more credible.
At trial, the functional concern is perceived credibility: how believable the expert seems to those deciding the case. That’s not the same as whether the expert’s opinion is correct. Research on juror perceptions of expert witnesses indicates that these judgments are based on four dimensions: perceived knowledge, perceived confidence, trustworthiness, and likability.[1] An expert’s credentials—and the qualification exchange culminating in counsel’s request that the court recognize the witness as an expert—establish perceived knowledge. But how the expert testifies, moment by moment, determines whether jurors perceive the expert as confident, trustworthy, and likable.
Why do these four dimensions matter so much for experts in particular? Dual-process models of judgment and decision-making distinguish a slower, analytical mode of evaluation that weighs evidence and logic from a faster, intuitive mode that relies on cues like demeanor, fluency, and easily recalled or familiar credentials. Unfamiliar technical testimony, tiredness, or incomplete understanding tend to push jurors toward the faster mode. In one study, mock jurors who heard highly scientific testimony were persuaded by an expert’s credentials, while those who heard simpler testimony paid closer attention to its substance.[2] The practical conclusion is that if jurors don’t quickly follow an expert’s reasoning, the quality of the analysis can be lost, and jurors’ ultimate understanding rests instead on more superficial impressions.
THE CURSE OF KNOWLEDGE
Once we know something, it becomes incredibly difficult to imagine not knowing it. Expert testimony can thus sound very different to experts (and to highly intelligent lawyers who are steeped in the particulars of a case) than it does to jurors. Terms an expert has used daily for decades start to feel like plain English, methodological steps and assumptions shared by colleagues with anything more than a passing knowledge of the field can go unstated. While the trial team perceives and understands a full explanation, the jury might only capture fragments, and because your usual audiences share your knowledge, experts may rarely receive feedback that can reveal the gap.
TEACHING FOR UNDERSTANDING
Knowing a subject and knowing how to teach it are different forms of expertise. Possessing credentials that comfortably satisfy qualification requirements is the minimum. Knowing how to convey that understanding to an audience with uneven levels of interest, like high school students, is a skill (or a series of habits to be developed) that can translate directly to success on the witness stand.
A good first step is for the expert and counsel to decide what their “students” must leave knowing. It has a small number of objectives: identify the two or three conclusions that jurors must retain and build the testimony around those points rather than around everything the expert knows. High school teachers also start from what students already can be reasonably presumed to understand, because new material sticks when it can attach to something familiar. In practice, this means starting with concrete examples before introducing abstract concepts. Once jurors understand the example, the expert can explain the underlying principle and show how it applies to the facts of the case or the technology at issue.
Teachers are also attentive to the limits of an audience’s working memory, which can be easily overwhelmed by too much new information conveyed too quickly. They introduce one idea at a time, define a term once and use it consistently, and leave out details and caveats that don’t change the conclusion. They regularly signal where a lesson is headed (e.g., “There are three steps to this analysis, and here is the first…”) so that listeners have a structure in which to place the information that follows. They watch for signs of confusion and return to complex bits when necessary. An expert cannot quiz a jury, but both expert and counsel should be attentive to it, and the expert and counsel can build necessary recapitulation into the direct examination.
Finally, teachers use the board. Visual aids and demonstratives are essential. They are how abstract relationships and concepts become concrete to visual learners. An expert who walks jurors through a diagram often looks less like a witness and more like a helpful teacher explaining an important (and new) understanding of how some aspect of the world works.
Clarity is not the same as oversimplification. Some might hear advice like this as an instruction to “dumb it down”—jurors are adults, many of them sharp, highly educated, and adept at detecting a condescending tone. An expert who addresses jurors like children will lose their respect as surely as one who addresses them like a faculty committee will lose their interest. Good teachers, however, don’t talk down to their students. They respect them enough to do the work of making difficult ideas clear without stripping out substance.
DEMEANOR: AVOIDING THE COMPETENT BUT COLD TRAP
The smartest-seeming person in the room is often not the most liked or the most persuasive. Research on social perception suggests that casual evaluation often occurs along broad dimensions of warmth and competence.[3] An expert who comes across as highly competent but cold and arrogant can fall into the trap of being respected without being believed.
Jurors are also less interested in who an expert is on paper than in whether the expert can reference real-world competence. As such, experts should provide evidence of both ability and objectivity.
Perceived confidence on the stand is not purely a matter of temperament. Experts who believe they can handle the task tend to appear calm and assured. Making the shift from merely possessing self-confidence to conveying self-efficacy to a jury can largely be a matter of asking, in advance, a few questions that a teacher asks before walking into a classroom:
- If a juror remembers only three sentences of the testimony, what should they be?
- What does someone with zero background in the field need to know before reaching the expert’s conclusion and feeling confident that it makes sense?
- Which terms are likely to be unfamiliar, and can each be replaced or defined simply and used consistently?
- What everyday or broadly familiar analogy captures the key concept?
If the testimony outline can satisfy these questions, the expert is likely on the right track. A useful test is to ask how the expert would explain his or her opinion to a bright high school sophomore who has never taken a course in the field. It also helps to rehearse with a lay listener rather than with members of the trial team who already understand the material. A listener who lacks familiarity can help identify gaps before the jury does. Experts are retained for what they know, but they persuade through what they can bring jurors to understand. The college lecture is for an audience that has opted in and done the reading, but borrowing from the craft of high-school teachers can give jurors an on-ramp to adopting your understanding of highly complex information and ultimately benefit your client.
Please stay tuned. In our next article in this series, we’ll discuss the teacher model and its uses in preparing testifying experts for cross-examination.
[1] Kahneman, 2011.
[2] Cooper, Bennett & Sukel, 1996.
[3] Fiske, Cuddy, & Glick, 2007