In the News
Nov 20, 2026

Not All Evidence of Trade Secret Misconduct Drives Damages Higher, New DOAR Study Finds

National study finds jurors do not treat all trade secret misconduct alike, responding most strongly to evidence of corporate planning and incentives.

National study finds jurors distinguish employee mobility and professional know-how from evidence of planned or incentivized corporate misconduct

November 20, 2026, New York, NY – DOAR today released findings from a new national study examining what drives jurors to increase damages in trade secret disputes. The report, Juror Attitudes Toward Damages in Theft of Trade Secrets Disputes: A National Study, finds that jurors respond most strongly to evidence that a company planned, encouraged, or financially rewarded misconduct, while other circumstances that may raise suspicion have far less impact.

Conducted by the DOAR Research Center, the study surveyed 1,855 U.S. adults and examines how damages assessments changed as respondents received additional facts about four hypothetical trade secret disputes. The scenarios explored deceptive acquisition efforts, corporate incentive programs, employee hiring, the use of knowledge gained at a former employer, and the transfer of confidential documents.

Key findings from the study include:

  • Corporate incentives produced the strongest reaction: In a scenario involving a foreign corporation accused of stealing an American company’s technology, the share of respondents assigning the maximum damages rating rose from 24% to 40% after they learned that the corporation paid large bonuses to employees who stole competitors’ trade secrets.
  • Evidence of premeditation increased damages: When respondents learned that corporate executives had used a sham acquisition process to obtain confidential information from a smaller competitor, the share assigning the maximum damages rating rose from 22% to 33%. 
  • Employee mobility and professional know-how had little effect: Hiring employees from a competitor and using knowledge acquired in a prior position did not meaningfully change damages assessments, even when the new employer developed a similar product in substantially less time.
  • Confidential documents changed jurors’ perceptions: Damages increased substantially when respondents learned that former employees had provided their new employer with confidential technical documents.

“The research shows that jurors do not treat every indication of trade secret misuse the same,” said Chad Lackey, Ph.D., Director at DOAR and author of the study. “What drives damages higher is evidence that transforms the conduct from an employee’s questionable decision into a deliberate corporate act. When executives plan the misconduct or create incentives for it, jurors see the company itself as responsible.”

The study identified a consequential distinction between conduct that may appear suspicious and conduct jurors consider serious enough to warrant higher damages. Respondents generally did not increase damages when employees relied on experience or knowledge acquired in a former position. They reacted far more strongly when executives planned or rewarded the misconduct, or when employees transferred confidential technical documents.

“These findings reinforce the importance of identifying the evidence that will matter most to jurors rather than assuming every suspicious fact will carry the same weight,” said Paul Neale, CEO of DOAR. “By testing how jurors interpret employee conduct, executive involvement, and the use of confidential information, legal teams can better understand which facts influence jurors’ views of alleged misconduct and potential damages.”

The full report, Juror Attitudes Toward Damages in Theft of Trade Secrets Disputes: A National Study, will be available at DOAR.com.

About DOAR

DOAR is a litigation strategy consulting company that provides legal teams with strategic clarity, expert insight, and thoughtful perspectives to win complex, high-stakes matters. By bringing together leading litigation strategy consultants and highly qualified testifying experts under one roof, DOAR helps clients develop stronger cases that drive better outcomes.

For more information about DOAR, visit DOAR.com and follow us at @DOARlitigation.

Media Inquiries:
Cindy Siegel
Vice President of Marketing
media@DOAR.com

Stay Informed
Stay up to date on our latest news and insights.
Subscribe
Read More
3d black and blue abstract
In the News
Aug 10, 2026
NEC Secures $20.5 Million Patent Verdict Against Peloton in Streaming Technology Dispute

The jury found that Peloton directly infringed four asserted patent claims and rejected Peloton's invalidity defense.

Read Now
close up metal texture bumps
In the News
Jul 16, 2026
Jury Delivers Record Verdict Against Online Ghost Gun Seller Husky Armory in Kentucky Teen’s Wrongful Death Lawsuit

The verdict, $4.2m in compensatory damages and $100m in punitive damages, sends a powerful message to the ghost gun industry.

Read Now
light trails with a flowing, dynamic motion
In the News
Jun 24, 2026
Defense Prevails in High-Stakes Section 16(b) Securities Trial Seeking More Than $500 Million in Disgorgement

DOAR supported Empery Asset Management and Brio Capital in a Section 16(b) defense verdict involving Kartoon Studios.

Read Now
Bryne Win Against Ameris Bank
In the News
Jun 16, 2026
Nearly $80 Million in Damages Awarded to Former Balboa Capital CEO in High-Stakes Contract Dispute Against Ameris Bank

A federal jury returned a sweeping victory in favor of former bank executive Patrick Byrne in his dispute against Ameris Bank.

Read Now
black and white curve lines with shadows
In the News
May 28, 2026
New DOAR Research Identifies Key Factors Shaping Liability Decisions in Civil Cases

Five-year analysis finds gender, socioeconomic status, and perceived case strength shape how jurors evaluate liability.

Read Now
black and white image with blur illustrating movement
In the News
Mar 30, 2026
SiriusXM Defeats Patent Claims in Delaware Bench Trial Win

Following a bench trial in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware, the court entered final judgment in favor of SiriusXM, holding that Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft’s patent infringement claims were barred by equitable estoppel. DOAR supported defense counsel at Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer LLP with an integrated approach encompassing strategic advising, graphics consulting, and evidence presentation.

Read Now
black and blue lines fanning out from center point
In the News
Mar 26, 2026
Two-Thirds of Americans Support Liability for Chatbot-Related Suicides, New DOAR Study Finds

National survey highlights strong support for AI safety guardrails and reveals generational differences in attitudes toward chatbot accountability.

Read Now
copper and grey thick lines with gloss
In the News
Mar 19, 2026
DOAR Report Highlights Key Trends in 2025 ITC Section 337 Investigations

Our latest ITC report reveals renewed activity at the International Trade Commission, evolving technology focus areas, and emerging patterns shaping investigations.

Read Now