These results also show that there were substantial portions of respondents who also ranked punishment and fairness lower on the list. In fact at the bottom of their list. For example, the largest group of respondents (28%) rated punishment as their top concern, but 21% ranked it as their lowest. Similarly, while the largest group of respondents (28%) ranked fairness as their top concern, 25% ranked it as their least important concern.
We looked at these divergent populations and compared those who value punishment the most versus those who value it the least. And we did the same for fairness.
Let’s first look at the issue of punishment. We compared those who ranked punishment as their top two most important concerns with those who ranked it their bottom two. We omitted those who ranked it in the middle. Those who value punishment the most were more likely to be Republicans and reside in a rural area. Those who value punishment the least are progressives and Democratic Socialists.
Additionally, those who value punishment the most award more damages than those who value it the least. This held true for scenarios 1, 2, and, for the most part, 3. However, it did not hold true for scenario 4. This is likely because they believed the fact patterns in scenario 4 were less unacceptable, and not deserving of punishment, as compared to the fact patterns in other scenarios.
A similar, but reversed, pattern emerged for those who value fairness the most versus those who value it the least. To begin, younger respondents, African Americans, Hispanics and those with less education were significantly more likely to value fairness the most. In contrast, fiscal Republicans were significantly more likely to value fairness the least. As far as damages are concerned, those who are most concerned about fairness award significantly lower damages than those who are least concerned about fairness. This held true in all 4 scenarios and with each additional fact. The only exception was scenario 4. While those who value fairness the most awarded lower damages than those who value it the least, the differences were not significantly different. This suggests that both groups, as did most, did not perceive the initial fact pattern as particularly unfair.
We also asked respondents to identify what would be most important for them when determining damages in a case where a large American corporation was found to have stolen trade secrets from a small American company. Respondents were then presented with a similar list as before, with a few additions.
- Avoid awarding so much that the large corporation is forced to lay off workers
- Avoid awarding so much that it bankrupts the large corporation
- Punishing the large corporation
- Deter the large corporation from stealing trade secrets in the future
- Only make the large corporation pay for the harm it caused, no more
- Award only what is supported by the evidence
- Find a middle ground that is fair to both sides
Among this list of goals or concerns are five options often associated with limiting damages. These are options 1, 2, 5, 6, and 7. The others, punishment and deterrence, are often associated with increased damages.
In situations where a large tech corporation steals trade secrets from a small company, the majority of respondents (53%) state they are most concerned with punishment and deterrence. Fifteen percent are most concerned with potential layoffs and bankruptcy, 9% are most concerned with compensating victims for the harm, 14% are most concerned with evidence and 10% were most concerned with finding a middle ground.
When asked about their most important concerns when a small company steals trade secrets from a large tech corporation, the pattern reverses. In this situation, only 35% are most concerned with punishment or deterrence. Almost two-thirds are most concerned with other things. Nineteen percent stated potential layoffs and bankruptcy are their most important concerns. Twenty-one percent are most concerned about only awarding damages supported by the evidence, 11% were most concerned about compensating the victim for their harm, and 14% were most concerned about finding a middle ground. In other words, people are much more interested in punishing Goliath rather than David, even if David is the bad guy.
We also asked respondents what would be their most important concern if a large foreign tech corporation steals trade secrets from a large American tech corporation and vice versa. Results showed a similar but more muted pattern. In a situation where a large foreign tech corporation steals trade secrets from a large American tech corporation, almost half (48%) are most concerned with punishment and deterrence. Fifteen percent are most concerned with awarding damages supported by the evidence, 11% are most concerned with compensating the victim for their harm, 12% are most concerned with finding a middle ground and 14% are most concerned with awarding damages that avoid causing layoffs or bankruptcy.
In a situation where a large American corporation steals trade secrets from a large foreign tech corporation, only 40% state they are most concerned with punishment and deterrence, down from 48% in the reverse scenario. Eighteen percent are most concerned with awarding only those damages supported by the evidence, 16% are most concerned with finding a middle ground, 16% are most concerned with avoiding potential layoffs and bankruptcy and 10% are most concerned with making the victim whole.
The smaller differences in these findings are likely because both the foreign and American corporations are large. There is no power imbalance or inequity that exists when considering small companies versus large corporations. What is most curious about these findings is that the majority are less concerned with punishment and deterrence as a whole when it comes to foreign versus American corporations. Given the prior findings regarding large corporations, it would be reasonable to expect the majority to favor punishment or deterrence whether the foreign or American tech corporation steals trade secrets. However, that was not the case.